Second Salem Brewing Co. (Craft Beer & Brewery in Whitewater WI)

Second Salem Brewing Co. sits on the edge of Cravath Lake in Whitewater, Wisconsin, and immediately makes you feel like you’ve stepped into a local folktale. The brewpub’s décor draws on the town’s witch‑y legends, and each pint seems to whisper a story from the misty waters outside. The brewers have a genuine knack for turning myth into malt, giving their craft beers names that sound like they belong in an old‑time tavern rather than a trendy bar.

The menu is a lesson in imagination without pretension. A unique beer flight lets you sample local flavors, while the high ceilings keep the place feeling as expansive as the lake itself. Walls are plastered with artwork that chronicles Wisconsin’s quirks and Whitewater’s spooky past, adding a dash of culture to every sip (the founders, who’d spent years swapping stories over ales, wanted the space to feel like a living museum). The cottage pie is a surprisingly stellar side, and the beers—each christened after a regional legend—are brewed with enough craftsmanship to make even the most sceptical palate sit up and take notice.

Why we love this brewery

What visitors love

Second Salem Brewing Co. offers an exceptional experience with excellent craft beer, great food, and attentive service in a unique atmosphere featuring local art. Visitors rave about the restaurant's cozy ambiance, delicious cuisine, and welcoming staff.

Looking for more breweries in Whitewater area?