von Stiehl Cider Bar (Craft Beer & Brewery in Algoma WI)

Von Stiehl Cider Bar sits on the edge of Algoma Harbor, a place that looks like it was painted by a tourist postcard and then given a serious upgrade. Since 1967 it has been Wisconsin’s oldest licensed winery, and the family that runs it treats the job with the reverence of a priest and the curiosity of a lab‑coated scientist. Over 40 wines, a parade of artisanal ciders, and a line‑up of handcrafted spirits flow from their European‑style underground cellars (the kind you imagine monks whispering to while polishing barrels).

The cider menu is the real show‑stopper: each brew is built from a single, carefully selected apple variety, so you can taste the orchard’s personality rather than a muddled fruit mash. The staff know the whole process better than most people know the back of their own hands, and they’ll guide you through the tasting with a grin that says “we love what we do”.

Sip your drink while the harbor stretches out like a glittering mirror, then retreat to the snug fireplace lounge for a moment of quiet that feels oddly celebratory. The whole experience is polished, personable, and unapologetically proud of its craft.

Why we love this brewery

What visitors love

Reviewers praise von Stiehl Cider Bar's diverse cider selection, knowledgeable staff, and welcoming atmosphere. A scenic seating area with harbor views adds to the charm. Excellent service and friendly staff make the experience enjoyable and memorable.

Looking for more breweries in Algoma area?