Molly Pitcher Brewing Company Taproom on High (Craft Beer & Brewery in Carlisle PA)

Molly Pitcher Brewing Company Taproom on High sits in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, and it’s a place where imagination meets malt in the most unapologetically tasty way. Their Black Powder Stout is a dark, velvety beast that punches you with roasted coffee and a hint of chocolate, proving that a stout can be both powerful and elegant without trying to sound like a philosophy lecture. The kitchen isn’t just an afterthought either; the Molly Tots—crisp, golden potatoes tossed in a secret seasoning—stand proudly beside a menu of burgers that could make even the most seasoned grill‑master blush.

Seasonal specials roll out with the punctuality of a Swiss watch, each one offering a fresh twist that keeps regulars coming back for the novelty and the quality. The atmosphere buzzes with high‑energy chatter, the kind that makes you feel you’re part of a secret society devoted to great beer and even better grub. (The founders, long‑time friends of the craft, decided early on that pretension had no place here.) Whether you’re after a bold new flavor or a classic burger done right, Molly Pitcher delivers without fuss, just pure, unpretentious craftsmanship.

Why we love this brewery

What visitors love

Reviewers praised Molly Pitcher Brewing Company Taproom for its excellent beer selection, with many enjoying the "Black Powder Stout" and "Peanut Butter Porter". Food is also highly rated, particularly the BBQ burgers and charred-onion cream sauce. Atmosphere and customer service are consistently praised.

Looking for more breweries in Carlisle area?