The Best Brewery/Microbrewery in Shelter Island, New York

Craft Beer & Microbrewery Guide for Shelter Island, NY

Unveil Shelter Island, New York - a captivating coastal gem where the Atlantic Ocean meets the vibrant spirit of artisanal brewing. Known for its tranquil beauty and laid-back vibe, this idyllic island harbors a thriving craft beer scene, with local brewmasters blending tradition and innovation to create unique, flavorful ales that encapsulate the island's allure in every sip. Explore Shelter Island, where the charm of secluded shores melds effortlessly with the zest of handcrafted beers, making it an essential destination for beer enthusiasts seeking unforgettable experiences off the beaten path.

Shelter Island Craft Brewery in Shelter Island, New York - 4.20 star rating

Shelter Island Craft Brewery

Shelter Island NY

4.20

Unique seasonal beers with creative flavor combinations

More breweries near Shelter Island, NY

Greenport Harbor Brewing Company in Greenport, New York - 4.60 star rating

Greenport Harbor Brewing Company

Greenport NY (3.9km)

Upscale tap list with many local brews

Kidd Squid Brewing Company in Sag Harbor, New York - 5.00 star rating

Kidd Squid Brewing Company

Sag Harbor NY (8.8km)

Wide selection of craft beers available

Greenport Harbor Brewery and Restaurant in Peconic, New York - 4.50 star rating

Greenport Harbor Brewery and Restaurant

Peconic NY (10.2km)

Unique seasonal beers capturing Long Island spirit

Eastern Front Brewing Co. in Mattituck, New York - 4.80 star rating

Eastern Front Brewing Co.

Mattituck NY (18.5km)

Boutique-like atmosphere with fancy cocktails.

The Clam Bar @ Alize Brewing in Mattituck, New York - 4.70 star rating

The Clam Bar @ Alize Brewing

Mattituck NY (19.2km)

Unique beer with fruit notes sets it apart

Jamesport Farm Brewery in Riverhead, New York - 4.20 star rating

Jamesport Farm Brewery

Riverhead NY (24.1km)

Huge variety of beers available on tap.