Gene McCarthy's Old First Ward Brewing Company (Craft Beer & Brewery in Buffalo NY)

Gene McCarthy’s Old First Ward Brewing Company in Buffalo, New York is a place where the beer flows as freely as the Niagara Falls and the wings are so good they might as well be a national treasure. The moment you step inside, you’re greeted by a bar that looks more like a laboratory for liquid gold than a pretentious hipster den. The line‑up is impressive: from crisp pale ales that bite like a fresh snowstorm to robust stouts that linger like a winter night. But the real show‑stopper is the Sheffield‑style wings – large, juicy, and crisp, with a medium‑spice level that hits the palate (a balance rarely achieved by amateurs) with the precision of a well‑timed joke.

The staff are friendly enough to make you forget you’re being served; they actually care about the brew, pouring each pint with the reverence of a priest at a ceremony. If you can stomach the occasional brag about their “excellent flavor profile,” you’ll leave with a grin wider than the Erie Canal. In short, Old First Ward delivers great beer, superb wings, and a vibe that says “we know what we’re doing” without the smugness.

Why we love this brewery

What visitors love

The Old First Ward Brewing Company offers an excellent atmosphere, exceptional staff, and delicious chicken wings with unique flavors, including peppery and spicy options, making it a standout spot among other Buffalo Irish pubs.

Looking for more breweries in Buffalo area?